The 1031 exchange is a taxation law that applies only to real estate investors and thus permits them to exchange one property for another, within a specific time period as dictated by the applicable rules, which thereby precludes them from having to pay a capital gain on the purchase of a like-kind property, which quite obviously is beneficial because there are no immediate tax consequences, because those capital gains have been deferred, thus permitting that investor to keep all of their money in play, and not have any of such siphoned over to taxation.
When it comes to stock equities, there is no such thing as a 1031 exchange, and the tax code specifically forbids such. Still, as in just about anything when it comes to taxes, these tax codes are subject to change, as well as being subject to review, which thereby means that if there was an effort to put forth to present a proposal for a 1031 type exchange for stock equities, that those who currently sell one stock to subsequently purchase another which means that they have to pay a capital gain on what they have sold would thereby have an avenue to defer their capital gain if a 1031 for stock equities was legislated into existence.
Indeed, investors sell stocks for all sorts of reasons, one of which is that they prefer to put their investment into a different stock equity, of which a modified 1031 would permit them to do so without having to suffer the proximate hit from a capital gains tax. On the other hand, some people sell their stocks because they need to scare up money to pay bills, or to purchase something else, and thus these folks would still be subject to an immediate capital gains tax.
It just seems sensible for investors who are staying within the same domain to have the option to defer capital gains when they essentially migrate from one specific stock investment to another stock investment, and are therefore not desiring to actually cash out any capital gain profit that they have achieved. No doubt, investors of all sorts would embrace this, being the case for stock equities, so being sold under a 1031 exchange program, which would seem to signify that our legislators should at least consider bringing this to the table for a debate and discussion.
While it is true that with a stock equity 1031 exchange that there would be a reduction in capital gains taxes captured by the tax authorities, it needs to be recognized that those capital gains would still be available for the government to be taxed, once they are sold for cash, so that the argument could be made that these aren’t really capital gains that have been eliminated, because they haven’t been, but rather these are capital gains that have been deferred, and since this government seems to believe that investing in stock equities is good for America and thereby good for American businesses, then a 1031 exchange for stock equities would appear to be something of merit, to seriously consider.